Caps Season Ticket Holder Gift Quandry

The other day, as part of my Caps season tickets, I received my order form for this year's season ticket gift. This year's gift is my choice of an autographed stick either by Olie Kolzig or Alex Ovechkin. This is a difficult decision on my part as I like both players a lot. Olie only has a few seasons left and holds all the Caps goaltending records, whereas, Alex is up and coming and is going to be a superstar in the league. I will be happy with either or, but since I have to choose, I am not sure which one I should choose.